Offshoring has become a buzzword in the business world, especially in discussions surrounding global trade and employment. U.S. companies have embraced offshoring as a strategy to improve their bottom lines, boost operational efficiency, and remain competitive in the global market. However, for business owners, managers, entrepreneurs, and professionals, the decision to offshore comes with significant implications.
This article addresses the meaning of offshoring, how it impacts the U.S. economy, and the pros and cons that offshoring brings to businesses. We'll also discuss the difference between offshoring vs outsourcing, providing practical examples to help you better understand this global business strategy.
What is offshoring?
Offshoring refers to the relocation of a company’s business processes, services, or production to another country, typically to take advantage of lower labor costs or favorable economic conditions.
“As the founder of a US-based shoe repair company, I have seen the impact of offshoring firsthand,” says Eric Neuner, founder and President of NuShoe, a shoe renewal, repair, and resoling company. “For my company, offshoring shoe manufacturing to Asia has been necessary to compete on price.”
While manufacturing was the first sector to implement widespread offshoring, today it’s common in industries like technology, customer service, and finance. But what does offshoring mean in a practical sense? It might involve a U.S. company moving its production facility to China or India, where labor costs are significantly lower. Or it could mean setting up a customer service center in the Philippines.
Offshoring is different from merely exporting goods—it involves the establishment of operations in another country to perform tasks or processes that were once done domestically.
So, what are the two types of offshoring? The two primary types are:
- Captive offshoring: This involves a company establishing its own subsidiary or branch in a foreign country. In captive offshoring, the business retains full control over the operations and management of the offshore facility. This model is often used by companies looking to maintain quality standards, protect intellectual property, and ensure direct oversight of their offshore operations.
- Contract offshoring: In this model, a company outsources specific functions or processes to a third-party service provider located in another country. The offshore provider is responsible for managing the operations, and the company pays for the services rendered. Contract offshoring is commonly used for functions like customer service, IT support, and manufacturing.
Outsourcing vs offshoring: Key differences
What is offshoring vs. outsourcing? Although they're often used interchangeably, they're distinct concepts:
- Offshoring refers to moving a company’s operations to another country, but the company retains control over these functions.
- Outsourcing means contracting out a portion of business processes to a third-party provider, which could be located either domestically or abroad.
So, what is an example of offshoring? A company might offshore its manufacturing to China while keeping the operation under its control. And outsourcing? It could outsource its customer service to a call center in the Philippines. Sometimes, companies engage in both offshoring and outsourcing—for example, outsourcing IT services to a company that handles its operations offshore.
Effects of offshoring in the U.S. economy
Offshoring is often a hot topic in the U.S. due to its perceived impact on local jobs and the economy. “For U.S. companies, it often means losing jobs and revenue,” Neuner says. “However, offshoring also allows companies to lower prices for consumers and focus domestic efforts on higher-value work.”
According to a study by the National Bureau of Economic Research, industries like manufacturing saw large portions of their workforces displaced due to offshoring, but the overall economic effects are more complex.
On one hand, U.S. companies that offshore often report lower operational costs and increased profitability, which can lead to more investment and growth. On the other hand, job losses in certain sectors have sparked debates about the long-term effects on workers and communities.
Some proponents of offshoring argue that the process can lead to a reallocation of resources, which, in theory, should benefit the U.S. economy in the long run. The argument goes that by outsourcing lower-skill jobs, the U.S. can focus on higher-value sectors such as technology, research, and innovation, which could create better-paying jobs for skilled workers.
A 2017 Forbes article indicated that U.S. firms saved billions by offshoring services like software development and call centers. But at the same time, offshoring was criticized for fostering wage stagnation and economic inequality within the U.S.
While offshoring may seem like an all-pro, no-con move for businesses trying to cut costs, in fact there are both offshoring pros and cons.
Pros of offshoring
What are the pros and cons of offshoring? Let’s begin with the offshoring benefits that can boost overall business performance for business owners, managers, and entrepreneurs:
- Cost savings: The primary reason businesses choose offshoring is cost reduction. Countries like India, China, and Mexico offer skilled labor at a fraction of the cost of U.S-based workers. By offshoring certain tasks, companies can save significantly on wages, benefits, and even taxes.
- Access to global talent: Offshoring gives companies access to a diverse pool of talent. Many countries specialize in certain fields, such as tech and IT services in India or manufacturing in Southeast Asia. This can improve the quality of the work done and enhance innovation in your business.
- Increased efficiency: Businesses that offshore specific tasks often benefit from a 24/7 workflow. For example, an offshored team in a different time zone can handle tasks overnight, effectively giving companies the ability to run around the clock.
- Focus on core business functions: By offshoring non-core activities like customer service or accounting, businesses can concentrate their resources on core functions such as product development, marketing, and strategy. This allows them to improve their competitive edge.
Cons of offshoring
There are some potential disadvantages of offshoring that business leaders should weigh carefully:
- Job loss in the U.S.: One of the most controversial effects of offshoring is the displacement of American workers. As businesses move jobs abroad, local employees, especially in industries like manufacturing and customer service, may find themselves out of work.
- Quality control challenges: Managing a team or process remotely can present difficulties, especially when there are differences in time zones, language, or work culture. Ensuring consistent quality from an offshore operation requires vigilant oversight, which may be difficult and costly.
- Negative public perception: Offshoring can harm a company’s reputation, especially if customers or the media highlight job losses or exploitative labor conditions in foreign countries. Public relations crises surrounding offshoring have led some businesses to reconsider their strategies.
- Potential for intellectual property risks: Operating in another country may expose businesses to higher risks of intellectual property theft, particularly in regions where protections are weak or poorly enforced. This can endanger trade secrets or proprietary processes.
That said, this is a problem mainly when a business does outsourcing. “Offshoring has a comparatively low data risk because a company has control over the team involved in the business operations,” says Mike Falahee, a business professional and entrepreneur who has scaled multiple companies past seven figures in yearly revenue, and the current president of Marygrove.
Key steps for successful offshoring
Successfully offshoring requires careful planning and execution to ensure that the transition is smooth and beneficial for your business. By taking a structured approach, companies can minimize risks and maximize the advantages of moving operations abroad.
Here are several essential steps to consider when developing your offshoring strategy:
1. Assess business functions for offshoring
Begin by evaluating which functions of your business are suitable for offshoring. Consider factors such as cost, complexity, and the level of expertise required. Repetitive tasks require lower skill levels, or can be easily managed remotely are often good candidates. This could include customer service, IT support, data entry, or manufacturing processes.
2. Research potential countries and labor markets
Once you have identified which functions to offshore, research potential countries where these tasks can be performed effectively. Factors to consider include labor costs, language proficiency, cultural compatibility, legal requirements, and political stability. Countries like India, China, and the Philippines are popular offshoring destinations due to their established labor markets and expertise in specific sectors.
3. Establish clear protocols for managing offshore operations
Developing clear guidelines and protocols for managing offshore teams is critical for maintaining quality and ensuring smooth communication. This includes defining roles, responsibilities, and performance metrics, as well as implementing effective communication channels to facilitate collaboration. Regular check-ins and progress updates can help address any issues that arise and keep the project on track.
“Small businesses save costs, work with experts, and benefit from flexible work terms through offshore arrangements,” Falahee says. “However, communication issues might limit the success of the offshoring efforts.”
4. Build strong relationships with offshore partners
Successful offshoring often hinges on building strong relationships with your offshore partners. Take the time to understand their culture and work practices, and establish trust through open communication and transparency. Regular visits and face-to-face meetings can strengthen these relationships, fostering a collaborative environment that benefits both parties.
5. Monitor and evaluate performance
After offshoring, continuously monitor and evaluate the performance of your offshore operations. Use key performance indicators (KPIs) to measure success and identify areas for improvement. Be prepared to make adjustments as necessary to ensure that the offshored functions meet your business goals and maintain the desired quality standards.
6. Consider a hybrid model
For many businesses, adopting a hybrid model that combines offshoring with domestic operations can provide a balanced approach. This allows you to leverage the cost savings and efficiency of offshoring while retaining critical functions or oversight domestically. A hybrid model can also mitigate risks associated with offshoring, such as quality control and communication challenges, ensuring that your business remains agile and competitive.
“We have kept high-skill jobs like quality control and customer service in the U.S.,” Neuner says. “This hybrid model allows us to balance costs and quality. We inspect and correct any issues with offshore products before they reach customers.”
Offshoring examples of U.S. companies
The best way to understand and define offshoring is to look at some practical examples of how major U.S. companies have successfully utilized offshoring to drive their business goals while navigating the complexities of managing operations abroad.
Apple Inc.
Apple offshores the majority of its manufacturing to China. By partnering with companies like Foxconn, Apple takes advantage of lower production costs while maintaining quality control and oversight. This strategy has helped Apple stay competitive in the global market while keeping product prices relatively stable.
IBM
IBM is another U.S. company that offshores its services. In the early 2000s, IBM began offshoring thousands of IT and customer service jobs to India. This move allowed the company to reduce costs and invest in emerging technologies, maintaining its position as a tech leader.
General Motors
General Motors (GM) has offshored significant portions of its production to Mexico. While this move has lowered the company's labor costs, it has also led to public criticism, especially from U.S. workers and labor unions.
These examples highlight both the benefits and challenges that come with offshoring in real-world scenarios.
Bottom line: Is offshoring a good strategy?
Offshoring can be a powerful tool for business owners and managers looking to improve efficiency, cut costs, and stay competitive in a global economy. However, it’s not without its risks. Before deciding to offshore, it’s essential to weigh the potential savings against the challenges of quality control, public perception, and the impact on your U.S. workforce.
“Offshoring and outsourcing are controversial but increasingly unavoidable in a global economy,” Neuner says. “For companies, the key is using them strategically to focus on your strengths while maintaining quality and service. Consumers benefit from lower costs but must demand high standards. Flexible, balanced approaches tend to work best.”
For U.S. business owners, managers, and entrepreneurs, the key is understanding the offshoring advantages and disadvantages, trade-offs and developing a strategy that aligns with your business goals.
Get a remote job on The Muse—and find the flexibility you’re looking for »