Selling property is a big deal, and it's totally common not to know how to price a house for sale without doing some research about it. Sure, you want to maximize your profit, but setting the price too high or too low can hurt your chances of making a successful sale. The key is finding that sweet spot where buyers feel like they’re getting a fair deal, and you walk away satisfied with the outcome.
We asked real estate experts to break down exactly how to price your house to attract buyers and get the best return on your investment. We also cover the common pitfalls of pricing too high or too low, with by actionable steps you can take to set the right price.
Why getting the price right is so important
Pricing your home correctly is a delicate balance. Too high, and you risk scaring off potential buyers. Too low, and you leave money on the table.
“Pricing a house correctly reduces the time it spends on the market, speeding up the selling process,” says real estate broker Brady Bridges. “Accurate pricing helps one to reach the right audience and increase sales.”
Danger of pricing too high
It’s tempting to aim for the stars when you’re selling your house, especially if you’re emotionally attached to it or you’ve invested in structural and decor upgrades. But overpriced homes often sit on the market longer, making buyers wonder if something is wrong with the property.
“Even a beautiful home that meets buyers' wants might lose value as it sits on the market due to overpricing,” Bridges says. “The property grows less appealing over time, so it gradually lowers the price.”
Problem with pricing too low
On the flip side, underpricing your home may seem like a good way to generate interest and spark a bidding war, but this tactic can backfire. You might get more eyeballs on your listing, but there's an obvious problem of lower gains. Who wants to end up settling for less than what your home is truly worth?
“A dramatically underpriced home can also trigger buyer suspicions,” Bridges says. “Queries about hidden property issues may affect the negotiation process.”
New home…new job? Check open jobs at The Muse to financially prepare for your next big move »
Step-by-step guide on how to price a house for sale
So, what's the best strategy for pricing a home at that perfect price point? Here’s how to price your house for sale to maximize your potential while attracting the right buyers.
1. Research the market
The first step in figuring out how to price your house is researching your local housing market. What are homes in your neighborhood selling for? Look at homes similar in size, condition, and features—these are your “comps” (comparable properties). “Check sites listing recent nearby sales with details and photos of similar properties,” says real estate consultant Ashley Gawley. “See which are most comparable based on factors like square footage, lot size, age, and amenities.”
2. Get a professional home appraisal
Hiring a professional appraiser can provide you with an unbiased, accurate assessment of your home’s value. An appraiser evaluates your home based on factors like location, size, condition, and comparable recent sales. This can be especially helpful if your home has unique features that make it hard to compare with others.
3. Factor in market conditions
The state of the housing market plays a huge role in pricing. Is it a seller’s market (where demand is high and inventory is low)? Or a buyer’s market (where there are more homes for sale than buyers)? In a seller’s market, you might have more room to price on the higher end. In a buyer’s market, it’s often smarter to price more competitively to stand out.
4. Consult with a real estate agent
One of the easiest ways to figure out how to price your home for sale is to consult a real estate agent. Agents know the local market inside and out and can help you set a competitive price. They’ll also use their expertise to adjust for things like school districts, proximity to amenities, or future developments in the area.
How do Realtors and other agents determine how to price a home? Gawley shares her process: “I use industry tools to analyze recent local sales of comparable properties to determine a competitive range, then inspect the home to consider upgrades and condition before recommending a price.”
5. Pay attention to online pricing brackets
How you price your house for sale online is crucial to getting maximum exposure. Buyers searching for homes online typically use price brackets to filter their options. For instance, someone might set a search filter for homes between $300,000 and $400,000. So if your house is listed at $405,000, you’ll miss out on potential buyers who might be willing to stretch their budget. Listing at $399,900 could attract significantly more interest than $400,100.
6. Keep emotions out of it
Selling a home can be emotional, but separate those feelings from the pricing decision. While your home may hold precious memories, potential buyers don’t have the same attachment. Stay objective by relying on data and professional advice rather than sentiment.
7. Be prepared to adjust
The housing market can shift quickly, so be flexible. If your home isn’t getting the traction you expected within a reasonable timeframe, you may need to reevaluate your price. That doesn’t necessarily mean slashing it drastically—sometimes a slight reduction can make a big difference.
“Be willing to negotiate,” Gawley says. “The key is balancing your needs and the market to get the highest price possible within a realistic range. With the right strategy and support, you can price to sell without leaving money on the table.” Monitoring buyer feedback and market activity will help you stay competitive.
Bottom line: The perfect price makes for a quick, profitable sale
Figuring out how to price your house for sale might feel overwhelming at first, but by doing your research, consulting experts, and staying objective, you can land on a price that attracts serious buyers while ensuring you get the most value. Remember, the goal is to find a price that reflects your home’s worth without driving buyers away.
If you’re priced too high, you risk watching your listing gather dust. Too low, and you might be selling yourself short. But with the right approach, your house can be priced to sell—without the minimum frustration and maximum profit.