Picture this: your friend just found the perfect apartment and needs a co-signer to make it happen. They turn to you, excitement written all over their face. But as you think it over, you can’t help but wonder about the implications. Should you really co-sign for the apartment? While stepping in can be a great way to help someone out, it also comes with serious risks that could affect your finances and credit.
In this article, we'll explain how cosigning works and explore the pros and cons so you can make an informed choice.
Money matters—but so does happiness. Browse these amazing opportunities on The Muse and find the perfect fit for you »
What is a co-signer for an apartment?
A co-signer for an apartment is someone who agrees to share the legal responsibility for the lease with the primary tenant. This often happens when the primary tenant has a limited credit history, a low income, or other factors that make it challenging to qualify for a lease on their own.
So, how does co-signing for an apartment work? Landlords typically require co-signers to go through a credit check, as a strong credit history and stable income are important. Your name will be included in the lease agreement, meaning you’ll be equally responsible for the lease. In other words, if the primary tenant fails to pay rent, you’re legally obligated to cover it.
This arrangement usually lasts for the entire lease term, so if the primary tenant wants to renew the lease or move out, you may need to be part of those discussions too.
Co-signer vs. guarantor
A co-signer and a guarantor are similar but not identical. Here's a breakdown of the differences:
- Liability: “A co-signer is typically liable for the entire amount of rent or any damages incurred by a tenant, while a guarantor has a limited liability and may only be responsible for certain aspects of the lease,” says Silvia Lupone, a seasoned real estate agent and owner of Stingray Villa.
- Rights: A co-signer is treated as a tenant, which means they have the same rights and responsibilities as the primary tenant. This includes having access to the property and being able to make decisions about it. On the other hand, a guarantor does not have any rights to the property and cannot make decisions about it.
- Duration of involvement: In most cases, a co-signer remains on the lease until its term ends or if both parties agree for them to be removed. However, a guarantor's involvement is typically limited and can end once certain conditions are met, such as when the tenant has established a good rental payment history.
- Credit check: Landlords may perform credit checks on both co-signers and guarantors, but they tend to place more emphasis on a co-signer's creditworthiness since they're ultimately liable for paying rent. However, a guarantor's credit will still be evaluated to determine their ability to cover any potential expenses.
Overall, both roles have financial implications, but a co-signer has more active involvement in the lease agreement while a guarantor is only financially liable.
Pros and cons of co-signing for an apartment
There are definitely benefits and drawbacks to consider before agreeing to co-sign for an apartment—and the perks aren't just limited to the eternal gratitude of the person you’re helping (though that’s a nice bonus). Here are some key points to keep in mind.
Pros
- You’ll help a loved one. By stepping in as a co-signer, you’re opening doors for someone who might otherwise be unable to secure a lease. “Co-signing makes it possible for people with insufficient credit ratings or income to get housing,” Lupone says.
- It will strengthen your relationship. Co-signing can be a gesture of trust and support, potentially strengthening bonds between friends or family members involved.
- It may boost your credit score. If you're wondering, “Does co-signing for an apartment affect credit?” the answer is yes, it might. If the primary tenant pays rent on time, it can reflect positively on both parties. This can help build or improve the co-signer's credit score over time.
- There’s opportunity for education. If the primary tenant is younger or less experienced, this can be a great chance for you to guide them on financial responsibility and how to handle rental agreements.
Cons
- It comes with financial risk. “If the tenant is unable to pay their rent, you're the one who is responsible for the rent payments,” Lupone says. This can strain your finances, especially if you're not prepared for unexpected expenses.
- It may negatively impact your credit score. Any missed payments by the primary tenant can negatively affect your credit score. Even if you’re not living in the apartment, you could face repercussions if the tenant doesn’t fulfill their financial obligations.
- You’ll have limited control. While you share the lease, you might have little say in the tenant’s decisions or behavior. If they don’t take care of the property or violate lease terms, you could be held accountable without being able to influence their actions.
- There’s potential for relationship strain. Money matters can complicate relationships. If the primary tenant has trouble meeting their obligations, it may lead to tension or conflict between you and them.
Is co-signing the right decision for you?
Deciding to co-sign for an apartment is a major step. “Co-signing can be positive if you are trying to assist a family or a close friend in finding a home, but it has its own disadvantages,” Lupone says. “If the renter defaults, you take the hit, and that can put a strain on your finances or credit.”
Evaluate the tenant’s trustworthiness and your capacity to shoulder the rent in case the need arises, and have a clear understanding of the responsibilities and potential risks involved before making a decision.
Remember, you have every right to decline being a co-signer if it doesn't align with your personal or financial goals. The decision should be made with careful consideration and open communication between all parties involved.